Raising the bar for all online publishers, Hulu has committed to only bill brands and agencies for ads that viewers watch in their entirety.
“This is an industry first,” according to Jean-Paul Colaco, Hulu's senior vice president, advertising -- explaining that the move is part of Hulu’s “all in” attitude. “Hulu advertisers will not be charged unless their advertisement has been streamed through completion.”
The 100% completion rate commitment includes all ads sold by Hulu itself, and will apply to both Hulu and Hulu Plus, Colaco said Tuesday.
In beta for several months, Zenith Media, General Mills, and Horizon Media all helped Hulu test its new model. The model has the ability to “minimize waste and maximize effectiveness of video advertising," Rick Hosfield, vice president of content planning and distribution at General Mills, stated.
More than a mere marketing gimmick, Colaco sees the move as an extension of Hulu’s intrinsic brand-friendly nature.
Bold as the offer may seem, however, it's important to note the difference between Hulu's play and YouTube's -- which is employing a pay-per-complete model, according to Michael Greene, an analyst at Forrester Research.
“What Hulu is doing is reinforcing its status as a premium video publisher by calling attention to its strong user engagement and ad completion rates -- metrics that differentiate it from other publishers, especially those in the mid- to long tail,” Green explains.
“YouTube, on the other hand, is trying to use consumer ad skipping to its competitive advantage. In a world where users can expect to skip video ads and advertisers pay for completes, only a publisher with the scale of YouTube can effectively compete on those terms," he adds.
As Forrester senior analyst Joanna O'Connell notes: “YouTube is also focused heavily on using data to better match advertisers' ads to consumers, based on the likelihood that the consumer will complete the ad. Using data to enhance targeting is smart.”
Conversely, in 2007, Hulu launched its ad selector, which encouraged viewers to choose among multiple ads to select the one most relevant to them. More recently, Hulu introduced its ad swap product, which lets viewers replace existing ads for those they feel are more relevant.
Since the launch of ad swap, Hulu has seen over 9 million substitutions, according to Colaco. The original Hulu service continues to ramp up users and content, while Hulu Plus -- the company’s U.S. subscription service -- passed more than 2 million paid subscribers in the first quarter of the year.
“Based on our research, Hulu Plus has achieved 2 million paying subscribers faster than any video subscription service -- online or offline -- in U.S. history,” per Colaco. There will be no extra cost to Hulu advertisers for this new guarantee.
There are a lot of problems with this. First of all not everyone needs to watch a whole commercial to get the message! Next they don't benefit from people who catch part of the commercial at one point in time and another part of it at a different point in time. Finally a commercial is still a commercial and there are far better ways to communicate brand messages.