“In a world where charlatans and mountebanks blather on about the impending horrors of climate change … one man stood up and said ‘NO.’ One crusader faced down the might of the liberal-Birkenstock complex and dared say what many had thought, but few had the courage to utter: ‘Climate change isn’t real because the Bible says it ain’t.’ He is … the man who brought a novelist to testify at a congressional hearing on environmental science. He is … the scourge of every scientist who dares uphold a century’s worth of climate measurements against the word of God. He is … Al Gore’s worst nightmare. He is … Jim Inhofe. Coming soon. To a Senate Environment and Public Works Committee near you. Again.”
Normally, the idea of someone in this day and age questioning climate change would not be funny. But I have to say, reading about Inhofe inspires hilarity like no other. I can only imagine the joy that must have arisen in the hearts of satirists and fake news anchors everywhere at the news. I can practically hear the cheering from the offices of “The Daily Show.”
But this is a marketing column, so I’m going to bite back the gorge, stem the flood of panic unleashed by this gentleman and instead look into how such belief systems can take hold — in other words, how even the most absurd ideas can take off when marketed well.
With the hope that in doing so, we can come up with some counter-measures. Because make no mistake, it’s game time for climate change activists. Time to step up to the plate and fight for the truth. Most importantly, find new ways to fight. The old ones aren’t working as well as they need to.
So: back to the Inhofe-meister. Why is his campaign so successful? Sadly, it comes down to three words much beloved of the ad community. Insightful. Singular. Passionate. When we use these words in agencies, or the marketing community, they’re usually positive, meant to praise an outstanding and effective campaign. Well, here’s a reminder: It works for the dark side, too. Just look at the key strategic drivers of the campaign:
Inhofe has followed through diligently on all of the above. In fact, he has consistently shown that he is willing to go to any lengths to defend his beliefs and vilify his opponents. He once asked Michael Crichton, the late author of "Jurassic Park," to testify at a Senate hearing on climate change; wrote a book about the purported “hoax”; and took the fight to the enemy by claiming that “actually, global warming can be beneficial to mankind,” leading to improvements in the environment and the economy.
Don’t laugh. Learn. The antidote to this kind of madness is not a shrug and a belief that eventually rational minds will prevail. That’s idealism, not marketing.
Instead, this reinforces another, oft-overlooked truth about marketing: you don’t have to convince everyone in order to be successful. All you need is a passionate and vocal few, and you’re in business.
So before I get terminally depressed at the state of the asylum, let’s talk about how we can fight back.
Let’s stop being alarmist and be a little more entertaining. Whoever said “fight fire with fire” clearly did not understand physics. You fight fire with water: and nothing douses inflammatory rhetoric faster than a splash of satire. See comic Sarah Silverman on women’s wage inequality. Much great comedy is born of anger — surely we can channel some of our frustration into a more entertaining and memorable format?
Secondly, let’s simplify the message. How about a simple chart that shows the accelerated pace of oceans rising, glaciers melting and coastlines disappearing? How about a “We hate Our Children and Children’s Children” campaign?
And, finally, find a way to stay top of mind. Scientists have posited that if average surface temperatures rise by 2 degrees Celsius, the effects are irreversible. How about a “heat clock” that shows how close we are getting to that and what the effects are?
But then again, maybe this is a huge conspiracy and the evil forces of Goremania are secretly lighting thousands of forest fires, submerging tropical islands and causing unseasonable snowstorms.
In which case, could I interest you in investing in a bridge?
Absolutely True! I knew that!
The propaganda machine is well oiled and connected to powerful governments and corporations and the insightful, singular and passionate are not. We need to address the systemic problem of how it is that a propagandist heads up the Senate Environment and Public Works Committee here in the United State of America. It really isn't a marketing issue but I appreciate Benny you working it in to a green marketing blog so at least more people are aware of the denier who isn't even a little itty bit humorous, but very malicious as are his cohorts.
If you want to see and hear from unfiltered voices I've spent the last couple of years curating a climate change special collection on EarthSayers.tv
(http://bit.ly/noonhoax) where you will find and hear from academics, consultants, scientists, students, indigenous peoples, citizens - the Insightful, Singular and Passionate. Over a 100 of them. For the researchers there is the lecture (video) of Naomi Oreskes (http://bit.ly/EarthSayerOreskess) and for the bookies her book, Merchants of Doubt: How a Handful of Scientists Obscure the Truth about Climate Change lays out the "marketing landscape."
As to heat maps, the latest are in a NASA presentation, Climate Change and the State of the Planet at http://bit.ly/heatedup.
I have known Senator Jim Inhofe for over 35 years. The man is as honest as your will find. Interestingly, the one word(s) that is missing from your post is "honest" or "honestly". I wonder why that is?
Craig, I appreciate your taking the time to comment. And you may well be right that the Senator is an honest man. Be that as it may, his views are dangerously misguided and will only pour fuel on the fires, metaphorical and real, that threaten to engulf our planet. Climate change is not a matter of debate: only the ways to address it are.
Ruth Ann, I'll certainly check it out. As you ay, this is a Green Marketing blog, but I do my best to show how we can use our marketing skills for good.